Swiss equities: Does company size determine performance?

investment viewpoints

Swiss equities: Does company size determine performance?

Johan Utterman - Senior Portfolio Manager

Johan Utterman

Senior Portfolio Manager

In our previous commentary, Johan Utterman's team showed how structural megatrends will have a strong impact on the sustainable success of Swiss companies in the future. There is also a second factor that is crucial for investors. Is it worth investing in large caps, or are small and medium-sized companies the ones that stand to generate higher returns over time compared with the wider market? We explain the advantages of SPI Extra over SMI and SPI and why small and medium-sized companies are a worthwhile core holding in a portfolio.

At CHF 1,183 billion, just 20 Swiss companies account for 74 percent of market capitalization.  The 80 medium-sized companies still account for CHF 365 billion in market capitalization (23 percent), while the 115 small caps account for only 3% percent.  But does the size of a company affect whether it is a good and safe investment for investors? (Source: Bloomberg as at 30 April 2019)

Let's take a first look at the performance of the past twenty years. There is a clear winner here: Swiss small and mid caps, measured by the SPI Extra, outperform the SMI and SPI by a clear margin:

Figure 1: Swiss small and mid caps better than the SMI for 20 years nowAM-Swiss-Equities-Campaign_2_LinkedIn-Facebook.jpg (1057277428)

Cummulative returns since inception of the SPIEX:  January 1996 – 30 April 2019 .  Performance metrics in CHF. Source: Bloomberg. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

But what are the reasons for this? Swiss companies in particular score points with regard to key financial figures such as earnings growth, profit margin, return on capital and dividend yield (Yields are subject to change and can vary over time). Small and medium-sized companies in particular appear promising, as they often produce innovative products and are characterised by innovative business models. 

In our opinion, this is particularly true in the fields of health, technology, automation and optimisation of logistics chains. Due to the smaller company size compared to large caps, it is generally easier for them to grow quickly. Another key reason for investing in this asset class is the quality of these companies. They often serve niche markets where they are world leaders and are well positioned to benefit from the solid fundamentals that support the development of the global economy. Tomorrow's winners will be determined primarily by structural trends. Climate change, demographics and inequality are among the megatrends that can contribute to new business dynamism. Thanks to their specialisation, Swiss small and mid caps have an advantage over large caps, which are involved in many business cases. 

The long-term figures speak for themselves: small and medium-sized Swiss companies outperform the SMI.

However, the average beta in cyclical sectors such as consumer staples, finance or industry is on average 10% lower than the SMI or SPI. This should be taken into account in active portfolio management. Sector allocation is an important tool for managing volatility and risk. Active stock selection within a given sector is the key factor for risk-adjusted returns. 

 

Appropriate valuation returns

Looking at the valuations, the situation has eased again. While in January last year they appeared to be still too high compared with the Swiss Market Index, they have since returned to normal. Against the backdrop of better growth conditions and the solid fundamental data of Swiss SMEs, the current valuation appears appropriate compared with the SMI. In our view, in a world in which economic development is currently slowing, high-growth equities should be rewarded with a valuation premium. This will close the valuation gap with the SMI.

It could prove expensive not to be invested. Because equity investments should be worthwhile at the moment, preferably in small and medium-sized Swiss companies.

Portfolio complementation with well selected small and medium-sized firms can significantly improve the risk-return ratio. First-class companies can still be found in all segments, and the creation of added value begins with a comprehensive analysis. When assessing whether a company can grow sustainably, the first question is whether the business model can sustainably play a leading role in one of the megatrends. Here, the smaller and medium-sized companies have an advantage over multiplayers due to their lean orientation.