investment viewpoints

Commodities strike back

Commodities strike back
Laurent Joué - Head of Systematic Alternatives and Lead Portfolio Manager

Laurent Joué

Head of Systematic Alternatives and Lead Portfolio Manager
Florian Ielpo - Head of Macro, Multi Asset

Florian Ielpo

Head of Macro, Multi Asset

In the latest instalment of Simply Put, we explore whether the recent strong performance of commodities is sustainable and whether there is still time for investors to benefit.   


Need to know

  • Commodity performance has been particularly strong this year, but the risks are also increasing. The entire commodity risk premium has adjusted.
  • Skewness in these markets has become more negative, and the percentage of markets in backwardation has reached a level not seen in the period 1990-2022.
  • While the commodity trend has moderated recently, the asset class is still going strong and its high carry should continue to benefit investors.


Commodities have recently experienced a period of growth and increased volatility. This is a rather unusual situation in the history of these markets and raises a key investment question: is there still time to gain exposure to commodities? The answer is twofold: commodity prices could still rise (demand remains strong and supply disrupted) and investors could also benefit from an abnormally high carry.  This second point could make a real difference in the coming months.

Let's first look at the mechanics of the commodity risk premium. Typically, demand plays a more important role than supply in commodity markets. Periods of growth, and thus of strong cyclical demand, tend to correspond to periods of rising cyclical commodity prices. In contrast, a contraction in demand resulting from a recession, for example, usually leads to a contraction in demand for commodities as well as a collapse in prices. In statistical terms, this leads the returns for most cyclical commodity markets to be characterised by a left skew. Statisticians refer to this as a “negative skewness”, as strongly negative returns occur more frequently than strongly positive ones. Academics tend to agree that a risk premium can be characterised by negative skewness. Another important element is that downturns are usually accompanied by increased volatility, so that returns and volatility are negatively correlated. In short, commodities are indeed a risk premium in this respect, as shown in Chart 1.


Chart 1. Skew and risk/return correlation among commodity markets

Multi-Asset-simply-put_skewness commodities.svg

Source: LOIM. Bloomberg. 1900-2022.


2022 may be giving the impression of a very different situation: strong demand combined with supply disruptions, following the pandemic and the Russian invasion of Ukraine, have generated a prolonged run of positive commodity returns. Yet commodity skewness has not become less negative – quite the contrary. The negative correlation between returns and volatility has grown. From this point of view, 2022 is characterised by an increase in the risk markers for any risk premium. The most logical consequence of this situation is a bigger commodity risk premium – investors should therefore expect to be compensated more for taking this risk through their carry. Yet, is this the case?

The combination of heightened commodities risk and the nature of this recent shock to commodities – a supply shock – has led to an increase in the usual carry for commodities. The disruption of supply has resulted in a significant part of the price increase taking place at the short end of the futures curve. For example, during 2022 the first futures contract for West Texas Intermediate (WTI) rose from $71 to $107 (reaching as high as $120), while the sixth contract only rose from $69 to $98 per barrel, i.e., an increase differential of 12%.  This phenomenon is not limited to the oil market but has spread to a very large number of commodities, as shown in Chart 2. Our analysis over the period 1990-2022 shows that 80% of commodity markets are currently in backwardation (when the current price of the underlying asset is higher than the price in the futures market), with a carry of around 10%. This level of carry may only have been exceeded 3% of the time during the period covered, but the percentage of the market in backwardation has been unprecedented. In our view, the carry of the asset class has largely aligned with the risk attached to it this year, suggesting commodities investors should continue to be rewarded for their exposure, this time through the increased carry associated with it. In a nutshell: the story of commodities is far from over, at least that is what market pricing seems to indicate.


Chart 2. Percentage of commodity markets in backwardation


Source: LOIM. Bloomberg. 1900-2022


Simply put, the recent increased risk for commodity markets is reflected in the term structure of futures; the resulting increase in carry should benefit commodity investors.




Macro/Nowcasting Corner

The most recent evolution of our proprietary nowcasting indicators for world growth, world inflation surprises and world monetary policy surprises are designed to keep track of the latest macro drivers making markets tick. Along with it, we wrap up the macro news of the week.

On the macro front, the news flow coming from Europe and China has been muted. In the US, the statistics are unanimous: US growth is strong. Private economists are now expecting 2022 growth to reach 3.2%, a high number given its recent range. The Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia’s outlook survey was 17.6 versus 21.4 expected and 27.4 in March: while it declined, this drop remained consistent with high growth. The leading index also fell from its highs of 2021 but pointed to a US economy on track with its potential at least (about 1.8%). This week’s housing data also showed signs of strength: housing starts remained strong while new home sales were still on an expanding path. The combination of all of these elements explains the growing confidence of the Federal Reserve in asserting its hawkish monetary policy. Not only are economic data strong: surprise indices for the US economy are positive and higher than their level at the end of 2019. This may come as a surprise to those discounting the negative impact from the combined commodity and monetary policy shock. The future of US growth keeps on dividing economists as charted below: when looking at the pool of economists forming the consensus available on Bloomberg, the spread between the minimum and maximum forecasts has progressively widened throughout the year. Interestingly, even the lowest of these forecasts (0.3%) currently does not foresee a recession: 2022 could be the first soft landing ever engineered by central banks.

Factoring in these new data points, our nowcasting indicators currently point to:

  • Still solid worldwide growth. The US and the Eurozone are showing solid numbers, while China remains set on a deteriorating path.
  • Inflation surprises should remain positive, but our signals have shown a recent decline. This decline follows the recent moderation of commodity prices, but not just this: 70% of the data constituting our inflation gauge is now declining.
  • Monetary policy is set to remain on the hawkish side, mirroring the strength of activity .


World growth nowcaster: long-term (left) and recent evolution (right)

Multi-Asset-simply-put-Growth nowcaster-26Apr-01.svg

World inflation nowcaster: long-term (left) and recent evolution (right)

Multi-Asset-simply-put-Inflation nowcaster-26Apr-01.svg

World monetary policy nowcaster: long-term (left) and recent evolution (right)

Multi-Asset-simply-put-Monetary Policy nowcaster-26Apr-01.svg

Reading note: LOIM’s nowcasting indicator gathers economic indicators in a point-in-time manner in order to measure the likelihood of a given macro risk – growth, inflation surprises and monetary policy surprises. The nowcaster varies between 0% (low growth, low inflation surprises and dovish monetary policy) and 100% (the high growth, high inflation surprises and hawkish monetary policy).

Wichtige Informationen.


Dieses Dokument wurde von Lombard Odier Funds (Europe) S.A. herausgegeben, einer in Luxemburg ansässigen Aktiengesellschaft mit Sitz an der Route d’Arlon 291 in 1150 Luxemburg, die von der Luxemburger Finanzmarktaufsichtsbehörde, („CSSF“), als Verwaltungsgesellschaft im Sinne der EU-Richtlinie 2009/65/EG in der jeweils geltenden Fassung und der EU-Richtlinie 2011/61/EU über die Verwalter alternativer Investmentfonds (AIFMD-Richtlinie) zugelassen wurde und deren Aufsicht unterstellt ist. Geschäftszweck der Verwaltungsgesellschaft ist die Errichtung, Vermarktung, Administration, Verwaltung und der Vertrieb von luxemburgischen und ausländischen OGAW, alternativen Investmentfonds („AIF“) sowie anderen regulierten Fonds, kollektiven und sonstigen Anlagevehikeln sowie das Angebot von Portfolioverwaltungs- und Anlageberatungsdiensten.
Lombard Odier Investment Managers („LOIM“) ist ein Markenzeichen.
Dieses Dokument wird ausschließlich zu Informationszwecken bereitgestellt und stellt weder ein Angebot noch eine Empfehlung zum Kauf oder Verkauf eines Wertpapiers oder einer Dienstleistung dar. Es darf nicht in Rechtsordnungen verbreitet, veröffentlicht oder genutzt werden, in denen eine solche Verbreitung, Veröffentlichung oder Nutzung rechtswidrig wäre. Dieses Dokument enthält keine personalisierte Empfehlung oder Beratung und ersetzt keinesfalls eine professionelle Beratung zu Anlagen in Finanzprodukten. Anleger sollten vor Abschluss eines Geschäfts die Angemessenheit der Investition unter Berücksichtigung ihrer persönlichen Umstände sorgfältig prüfen und gegebenenfalls einen unabhängigen Fachberater hinsichtlich der Risiken und etwaiger rechtlicher, regulatorischer, finanzieller, steuerlicher und buchhalterischer Auswirkungen konsultieren. Dieses Dokument ist Eigentum von LOIM und wird den Empfängern ausschließlich zum persönlichen Gebrauch überlassen. Es darf ohne vorherige schriftliche Genehmigung von LOIM weder ganz noch auszugsweise vervielfältigt, übermittelt, abgeändert oder für einen anderen Zweck verwendet werden. Dieses Dokument gibt die Meinungen von LOIM zum Datum seiner Veröffentlichung wieder.
Weder das vorliegende Dokument noch Kopien davon dürfen in die USA, in die Gebiete unter der Hoheitsgewalt der USA oder in die der Rechtsprechung der USA unterstehenden Gebiete versandt, dorthin mitgenommen, dort verteilt oder an US-Personen bzw. zu deren Gunsten abgegeben werden. Als US-Person gelten zu diesem Zweck alle Personen, die US-Bürger oder Staatsangehörige sind oder ihren Wohnsitz in den USA haben, alle Personengesellschaften, die in einem Bundesstaat oder Gebiet unter der Hoheitsgewalt der USA organisiert sind oder bestehen, alle Kapitalgesellschaften, die nach US-amerikanischem Recht oder dem Recht eines Bundesstaates oder Gebiets, das unter der Hoheitsgewalt der USA steht, organisiert sind, sowie alle in den USA ertragssteuerpflichtigen Vermögensmassen oder Trusts, ungeachtet des Ursprungs ihrer Erträge.
Datenquelle: Sofern nicht anders angegeben, wurden die Daten von LOIM aufbereitet.
Obwohl gewisse Informationen aus als verlässlich geltenden öffentlichen Quellen stammen, können wir ohne eine unabhängige Prüfung die Genauigkeit oder Vollständigkeit aller aus öffentlichen Quellen stammenden Informationen nicht garantieren.
Die in diesem Dokument geäußerten Ansichten und Einschätzungen dienen ausschließlich Informationszwecken und stellen keine Empfehlung von LOIM zum Kauf, Verkauf oder Halten von Wertpapieren dar. Die Ansichten und Einschätzungen entsprechen dem Stand zum Zeitpunkt dieses Dokuments und können sich ändern. Sie sind nicht als Anlageberatung zu verstehen.
Dieses Material darf ohne vorherige Genehmigung von Lombard Odier Funds (Europe) S.A. weder vollständig noch auszugsweise (i) in irgendeiner Form oder mit irgendwelchen Mitteln kopiert, fotokopiert oder vervielfältigt oder (ii) an Personen abgegeben werden, die nicht Mitarbeiter, leitende Angestellte, Verwaltungsratsmitglieder oder bevollmächtigte Vertreter des Empfängers sind. ©2022 Lombard Odier IM. Alle Rechte vorbehalten.