Nominal growth matters more than real growth – for now

In the latest instalment of Simply Put, we examine the recent resilience across equity markets and reason this is due to nominal growth having greater influence during periods of inflation than real growth. 

Since mid-March, the equity market has bounced back from a very rocky start to the year even though many factors point to the opposite result. Indeed, a commodity shock is usually detrimental to real growth and profits, while central banks’ hawkish actions to slow down inflation are typically a mid-term headwind for equities. To top it off, the future is not looking particularly bright as European and US sanctions against Russia are increasing. Nevertheless, equities are showing resilience. How can this be explained? First and foremost, we believe this is because corporate profits benefit from the nominal growth component of the economy – which is even more apparent today.

Chart 1 shows the decomposition of growth expectations between real growth and inflation in Europe and the United States in 2022.  Real growth clearly shows the first signs of a decline (about 0.5% over the last quarter in both regions). This is no surprise as GDP growth expectations have been revised down recently due to a combination of the Ukraine situation, higher commodity prices and higher rates – all of which are real growth headwinds. Yet, nominal growth is still increasing significantly thanks to inflation. Consequently, the real economy may be slowing down, but the nominal economy is still growing as inflation is rising faster than real growth declines. So, what matters most real growth or nominal growth?

Chart 1. Growth expectation decomposition in Europe (left) and the US (right): nominal versus real growth

Source: LOIM. Bloomberg. 2020-2022

To see which factor can explain equity movements, we regressed corporate profits for both nominal growth and real growth. Interestingly, both types of growth have equal explanatory powers (both long-term averages of the R-squared ≈ 50%) over the 1946-2022 period. The explanations however differ depending on the underlying regime. During inflationary periods (the ugly 1970s, 2007-2008 and 2022), nominal growth appears to determine corporate profits more than real growth. This could be explained by the fact that companies manage to pass on increasing prices to their customers: inflation is the reflection of what corporates do with their selling prices, as consumers show an acceptance of steeper prices. This has been apparent during the known periods of inflation shock – and the latest datapoint in Chart 2 looks to be comparable. Today, analysts anticipate a 9% rise in earnings, which corresponds to the 9% expected increase in nominal growth seen in Chart 1. Historically, a basic regression of earnings on nominal GDP growth would show that earnings progress by slightly more than 1.5x nominal growth. From this standpoint, analysts’ forecasts look conservative.

Chart 2. 3-year rolling R-square of corporate profits regressed on nominal growth and real growth

Source: LOIM. Bloomberg. 1952 - 2022

However, investors must be careful because these effects are temporary. For the moment, nominal growth is increasing but as central banks continue on their path to tame inflation, growth should also slow down to a point which is difficult to anticipate. Also, corporate costs are rising, so not all sales growth will become earnings growth. We expect both effects to be echoed in companies’ profit warnings for the quarter ahead during the current earning’s season.

Macro/nowcasting corner

The most recent evolution of our proprietary nowcasting indicators for world growth, world inflation surprises and world monetary policy surprises are designed to keep track of the latest macro drivers making markets tick. Along with it, we wrap up the macro news of the week.

In terms of macro data, this week has been light. In the US, the Service ISM index was expected to be 58.5, progressing from February’s 56.5 reading, and came in at 58.3. The service sector is clearly conveying the message that growth remains strong (see below chart). The combination of last week’s manufacturing ISM and this service component paints the picture of a very solid US economy. The Federal Reserve’s (Fed) minutes of its latest meeting, published on 6 April, added to this impression: the Fed intends to use quantitative tightening to slow down the economy, by selling USD 95 billion of bonds per month. This amount would be split between USD 60 billion of Treasuries and USD 35 billion of mortgage-backed securities, which compares with the peak rate of USD 50 billion a month the last time the Fed trimmed its balance sheet from 2017 to 2019. Over that period, it is worth noting that the Fed pushed 10-year rates to 3.26% on 12 October 2018. Back then, real rates increased to about 1.15% while inflation breakevens only rose to 2.17% – a very different situation from today. Our monetary policy nowcasters continue to indicate that central banks should keep on surprising investors with their hawkish tone in the months to come and the Fed’s James Bullard’s latest message hints at a net rise in short yields to 3.5%, which would imply a 100 bps curve inversion. This is a message all investors need to hear. However, the 2-10 slope declined to -200 bps in the 1970s and we are still very far from that.

In Europe, the macro data has probably been less negative than many expect. Retail sales in March remained on an uptrend, growing by about 5%, a high number by historical standards. Following on from consumer inflation reaching 7.5% , this week saw the publication of PPI inflation rising to 31.4%, one of the largest gaps ever seen between these measures. Finally, both German and French industrial production progressed year-over-year by about 2.5%, which is close to the historical average of the time series. Consistent with that, our growth nowcaster for the Eurozone remains strong and surprise indices are still in positive territory. The expected negative impact of the Ukrainian invasion is still nowhere to be seen but should start to appear by the end of April.

Finally, the Chinese economy continues show signs of distress: the Caixin PMI survey for the service sector showed a severe plunge (declining from 50.2 to 42). Recent lockdown measures are probably responsible for a large part of this collapse, but our nowcasting indicators still place China in a complex position from a macro standpoint.  The next weak point for the economy could be a slowdown in exports, as the rest of the world slows down but this is yet to come, as detailed previously.

Factoring in these new data points, our nowcasting indicators currently point to:

• Solid growth worldwide, with stronger momentum in the Eurozone, while China lags. Eurozone and Chinese data show a moderation and a renewed decline, respectively. This remains a very limited evolution.
• Inflation surprises should remain positive and all three zones (US, Eurozone and China) are rising. This is bad news for China, as the rise in commodities could further weaken consumers.
• Monetary policy is set to remain on the hawkish side. Recently our indicators have all moderated, even though it remains hard to read during this early evolution.

 
World growth nowcaster: long-term (left) and recent evolution (right)

World inflation nowcaster: long-term (left) and recent evolution (right)
   
World monetary policy nowcaster: long-term (left) and recent evolution (right)Reading note: LOIM’s nowcasting indicator gather economic indicators in a point-in-time manner in order to measure the likelihood of a given macro risk – growth, inflation surprises and monetary policy surprises. The Nowcaster varies between 0% (low growth, low inflation surprises and dovish monetary policy) and 100% (the high growth, high inflation surprises and hawkish monetary policy).

À l’usage des investisseurs professionnels uniquement
Le présent document a été publié par Lombard Odier Funds (Europe) S.A., société anonyme (SA) de droit luxembourgeois, ayant son siège social sis 291, route d’Arlon, 1150 Luxembourg, agréée et réglementée par la CSSF en tant que Société de gestion au sens de la directive 2009/65/CE, telle que modifiée, et au sens de la directive 2011/61/UE sur les gestionnaires de fonds d’investissement alternatifs (directive GFIA). La Société de gestion a pour objet la création, la promotion, l’administration, la gestion et la commercialisation d’OPCVM luxembourgeois et étrangers, de fonds d’investissement alternatifs (« FIA ») et d’autres fonds réglementés, d’organismes de placement collectif ou d’autres véhicules d’investissement, ainsi que l’offre de services de gestion de portefeuille et de conseil en investissement.
Lombard Odier Investment Managers (« LOIM ») est un nom commercial.
Ce document est fourni à titre d’information uniquement et ne constitue pas une offre ou une recommandation d’acquérir ou de vendre un titre ou un service quelconque. Il n’est pas destiné à être distribué, publié ou utilisé dans une quelconque juridiction où une telle distribution, publication ou utilisation serait illégale. Ce document ne contient pas de recommandations ou de conseils personnalisés et n’est pas destiné à remplacer un quelconque conseil professionnel sur l’investissement dans des produits financiers. Avant de conclure une transaction, l’investisseur doit examiner avec soin si celle-ci est adaptée à sa situation personnelle et, si besoin, obtenir des conseils professionnels indépendants au sujet des risques, ainsi que des conséquences juridiques, réglementaires, financières, fiscales ou comptables. Ce document est la propriété de LOIM et est adressé à son destinataire pour son usage personnel exclusivement. Il ne peut être reproduit (en totalité ou en partie), transmis, modifié ou utilisé dans un autre but sans l’accord écrit préalable de LOIM. Ce document contient les opinions de LOIM, à la date de publication.
Ni ce document ni aucune copie de ce dernier ne peuvent être envoyés, emmenés ou distribués aux États-Unis, dans l’un de leurs territoires, possessions ou zones soumises à leur juridiction, ni à une personne américaine ou dans l’intérêt d’une telle personne. À cet effet, l’expression « Personne américaine » désigne tout citoyen, ressortissant ou résident des États-Unis d’Amérique, toute association organisée ou existant dans tout État, territoire ou possession des États-Unis d’Amérique, toute société organisée en vertu des lois des États-Unis ou d’un État, d’un territoire ou d’une possession des États-Unis, ou toute succession ou trust soumis dont le revenu est imposable aux États-Unis, qu’en soit l’origine.
Source des chiffres : sauf mention contraire, les chiffres sont fournis par LOIM.
Bien que certaines informations aient été obtenues auprès de sources publiques réputées fiables, sans vérification indépendante, nous ne pouvons garantir leur exactitude ni l’exhaustivité de toutes les informations disponibles auprès de sources publiques.
Les avis et opinions sont exprimés à titre indicatif uniquement et ne constituent pas une recommandation de LOIM pour l’achat, la vente ou la détention de quelque titre que ce soit. Les avis et opinions sont donnés en date de cette présentation et sont susceptibles de changer. Ils ne devraient pas être interprétés comme des conseils en investissement.
Aucune partie de ce document ne saurait être (i) copiée, photocopiée ou reproduite sous quelque forme et par quelque moyen que ce soit, ou (ii) distribuée à toute personne autre qu’un employé, cadre, administrateur ou agent autorisé du destinataire sans l’accord préalable de Lombard Odier Funds (Europe) S.A. Au Luxembourg, ce document est utilisé à des fins marketing et a été approuvé par Lombard Odier Funds (Europe) S.A., qui est autorisée et réglementée par la CSSF.
© 2022 Lombard Odier IM. Tous droits réservés.